Home › Spanish & Colonial Homes

Spanish & Colonial style homes

Spanish and Colonial style homes, from 1920s originals to new construction

Red tile, plaster walls and arched windows; or clapboard, shutters and a columned front door. Built in 1927 or finished last year, here is how to recognize them, what to inspect, and how to choose between an original and a new build.

Spanish and Colonial style homes in the San Gabriel Valley range from 1920s originals to new construction. San Marino, Pasadena and Arcadia hold one of Southern California’s richest collections of originals: San Marino’s 2020 historic survey rated about 400 Spanish Colonial Revival and nearly 190 American Colonial Revival homes as significant or contributing. Andy Hsieh (CA DRE #01943789) helps buyers find, inspect and value both.

How to recognize the styles

Spanish Colonial

Asymmetrical massing, low-pitched roofs of clay tile, smooth plaster walls, arched doors and windows, patios, courtyards and loggias, with wrought iron, cast stone and decorative tile.

Colonial

Simple, symmetrical forms; hipped or gabled roofs, sometimes with dormers; clapboard or brick; paired double-hung windows; a classical front entry with pilasters, sidelights or a fanlight, and shutters.

Mediterranean

Formal, usually two stories and symmetrical, loosely modeled on Italian villas: a grand entrance, low hipped tile roofs, boxed eaves with carved brackets, stucco and wrought iron.

Monterey

California’s own blend of Spanish-Mexican and American colonial traditions: two stories, a restrained second-floor balcony, and stucco, brick and wood in combination.

Style descriptions follow the character-defining features listed in the City of San Marino’s 2020 Historic Resources Survey. New construction borrows the same vocabulary.

Original or new build?

1920s–40s originals

  • Craftsmanship and materials that are expensive to reproduce today
  • Provenance: some were designed by Wallace Neff, Roland Coate, Paul R. Williams and their peers
  • Mature lots and trees on established streets
  • If designated, a possible Mills Act property-tax reduction
  • Trade-off: aging systems, and limits on exterior changes if the home is designated

New construction in the style

  • Modern plumbing, electrical, insulation and energy performance
  • Open floor plans, larger kitchens, more bathrooms
  • A builder’s warranty and California’s new-home defect claim process
  • Solar is standard on most new California homes
  • Trade-off: build quality varies, and the details that make the style convincing (plaster, tile, window depth, waterproofing) are where corners get cut

What to inspect

On an original

  • Roof underlayment fails long before clay tile does.
  • Galvanized and cast-iron plumbing, plus the sewer lateral to the street.
  • Knob-and-tube wiring and undersized electrical service.
  • Foundation bolting and cripple-wall bracing.
  • Original casement windows: repair usually beats replacement.
  • Unpermitted additions: check the city’s permit history.

On a new build

  • Permits and final sign-off for every part of the house.
  • Water management: stucco weep screeds, window flashing, roof-tile underlayment and site drainage are where new Spanish-style homes most often leak.
  • The builder’s warranty and new-home defect paperwork, and the claim deadlines.
  • Solar: owned or leased, and what transfers with the sale.
  • Comparables: new builds compete with originals on the same street. Price against both.

For originals: designation, the Mills Act and San Marino

San Marino adopted a historic preservation ordinance in 2018 and completed a citywide survey in 2020. Being identified in the survey is not designation; per the city, designation is a separate process with public notice and review.

Designated landmarks and district contributors can apply for a Mills Act contract, which usually lowers property taxes in exchange for maintaining the property to the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards. San Marino’s contracts run 10 years and extend automatically each year. Applications are due June 30, and an eligible home can apply for landmark status at the same time. Cancelling costs 12.5% of the property’s current market value. Exterior changes to designated properties need a Certificate of Appropriateness.

The architects behind San Marino’s 1920s houses include Wallace Neff, Marston & Maybury, Harold J. Bissner, Carleton Monroe Winslow, Roland E. Coate, Frank D. Hudson, Paul R. Williams and Gordon Kaufmann. I publish a home’s architect only when two independent sources agree. See the “Did You Know?” series →

Sources: City of San Marino Historic Preservation program and Mills Act Guidelines; Citywide Historic Resources Survey Report (Architectural Resources Group, 2020). Confirm current rules with the city before relying on them.

Questions, answered

Do you only work with historic Spanish Colonial homes?

No. Andy works with Spanish and Colonial style homes from 1920s originals to new construction. Each has different strengths and different things to inspect; the right choice depends on how you want to live.

Is a new Spanish-style home a better buy than a 1920s original?

It depends on what you value. Originals offer craftsmanship, provenance, mature lots and, if designated, a possible Mills Act property-tax reduction, but their systems are old. New builds offer modern plumbing, electrical, energy performance, open floor plans and a builder's warranty, but build quality varies, and the details that make the style work (plaster, tile, window depth, waterproofing) are where corners get cut. Andy prices both against each other on the same streets.

How many Spanish Colonial Revival homes are in San Marino?

In the City of San Marino's 2020 Citywide Historic Resources Survey, roughly 400 single-family homes recorded as Spanish Colonial Revival were rated individually significant or contributors to eligible historic districts, along with nearly 190 American Colonial Revival, about 70 Mediterranean Revival and more than 40 Monterey Revival homes.

Does being in San Marino's historic survey mean my home is designated?

No. The city states that no property receives formal historic designation as a result of the survey; designation is a separate process with public notice and review. The survey identifies properties that appear eligible.

What is the Mills Act and can it lower my property taxes in San Marino?

The Mills Act is a voluntary contract between the owner of a designated historic property and the city: the owner agrees to preserve and maintain the property to the Secretary of the Interior's Standards, and in exchange the property is assessed under a formula that usually lowers property taxes. In San Marino, contracts run 10 years and renew automatically each year; applications are due by June 30, and owners of eligible but undesignated homes can apply for landmark status at the same time. Cancelling a contract carries a penalty of 12.5% of the property's current fair market value.